Rent vs Buy Calculator (First-Year Cost)
Buying builds equity, but owning has costs rent doesn't. This compares the unrecoverable costs of each for the first year.
How it's calculated
Owning cost ≈ mortgage interest + tax + upkeep + insurance + lost returns on the down payment − appreciation. Principal repaid isn't a cost, because it becomes equity.
Worked example
| Input | Value |
|---|---|
| Monthly rent | 2,000 |
| Home price | 400,000 |
| Down payment % | 20 |
| Mortgage rate % | 6.5 |
| Property tax % | 1.1 |
| Maintenance % of price | 1 |
| Insurance per year | 1,500 |
| Home appreciation % | 3 |
| Return on invested cash % | 5 |
| Result | Value |
|---|---|
| Renting costs per year | $24,000 |
| Owning costs per year | $22,700 |
| Owning minus renting | -$1,300 |
Questions
Why compare unrecoverable costs?
Rent, interest, tax and upkeep are money you don't get back. Comparing those is a fairer test than rent against the full mortgage payment.
Results are estimates for planning and education, not financial, tax or legal advice.
Related free tools
Loan payment calculator
Work out the monthly payment, total interest and total cost of any fixed-rate personal loan.
Mortgage payment calculator
Estimate your full monthly mortgage payment including principal, interest, property tax, insurance and HOA fees.
Home affordability calculator
Find the maximum home price you can afford from your income, debts, down payment and a debt-to-income limit.
Car loan calculator
Calculate your monthly car payment after down payment, trade-in and sales tax, plus total interest.
Down payment calculator
Calculate your down payment target and how many months it will take to save it, including interest on savings.
Loan comparison
Compare two loan offers side by side by monthly payment and total cost, including fees.